Andrew’s Easy 5 Minute Pizza Sauce Recipe

Want to make a delicious, easy, homemade pizza in no time? Here is Andrew’s recipe for the best 5-minute pizza sauce ever.

Who doesn’t love a delicious, warm pizza? I sure do. But sometimes the thought of making the sauce from scratch can be daunting. Never fear, Andrew has an easy 5-minute pizza sauce recipe that is simple and tasty.

All you need is a few common ingredients that you probably already have in your pantry. (all but one, and it’s the secret ingredient)

So keep on reading and get ready to cook and enjoy a homemade pizza tonight!

pizza sauce and pizza dough on counter
"This post may contain affiliate links which means I may earn a small commission. You may read my disclosure policy here".

How to Make Easy 5 Minute Pizza Sauce?

Before we begin, I would be remiss if I didn’t tell you, my sweet husband is not a certified chef. Truth be told, however, he has a fantastic repertoire of recipes tho.  Six! Six in total that is! 

This in no way is a complaint! On the contrary. When he does make his delicious meals, I’m totally thrilled! Whatever he chooses to cook, you know it’s going to be delicious because he has the tried and true method. Practice until it’s perfected!  

His recipes include Greens & Beans, Grilled Marinated Steaks, Ginger Salmon, Linguini & Clam Sauce, Hot dogs and steamers, and….scrumptious pizza! 

One day maybe I will share those recipes with you as well! (Would you like the linguini and clam recipe? Leave me a comment below!)

In the meantime, this post is dedicated to my sweet and darling husband. Without him, I would be lost! ūüôā 

Are you in the mood for a quick and easy pizza night?

Time to skip the jarred sauce and opt for homemade instead! 

Home-baking pizza is one of life’s simple joys.
The smell of fresh dough, fresh basil, and tomatoes in a wood-burning oven, the crisp crackle of cheese on top‚ÄĒit doesn’t get much better than this!

pizza dough being rolled out on counter

Homemade dough is the best! In this instance, Andrew used two store bought dough balls since he was short on time!

Andrew’s Easy 5 Minute Pizza Sauce Recipe

Want to make a delicious, easy, homemade pizza in no time? Here is Andrew's recipe for the best 5-minute pizza sauce ever.
5 from 2 votes
Prep Time 10 minutes
Cook Time 2 minutes
Total Time 12 minutes
Course Main Course, Side Dish
Cuisine Italian
Servings 6 people


  • Mixing Bowl
  • Pizza Peels
  • Ooni
  • Pizza Cutter


5 Minute Pizza Sauce

  • 14 oz Whole Tomatoes, skinless (preferably San Marzano Tomatoes)
  • 1 tsp Kosher Salt
  • 5-6 Basil Leaves (fresh preferred)
  • 1 tbsp Tuscan Herb Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Pizza Dough

  • 2 Homemade dough is preferable (In this case we are using store purchased dough – 2 round dough balls Cut dough in half for 4 individual pizzas


Pizza Sauce

  • In mIxing bowl add tomatoes, salt, basil leaves and olive oil

Pizza Dough

  • Roll out dough, flour on both sides
  • Ladle sauce onto pizza dough
  • Sprinkle grated cheese of choice on top, add fresh basil to top


  • Place on pizza peel
  • Lauch into Ooni for 1 to minutes (800-900 degrees)
  • Cut and serve
Keyword 5 minute pizza sauce
pizza sauce being ladled onto pizza dough
Ladle the sauce on top of your pizza dough

What Type of Cheese is Best for Pizza Making?

When it comes to making delicious homemade pizza, the type of cheese you use can make all the difference.

For a classic flavor, mozzarella is always a safe bet. Even better, for an added level of creaminess and flavor, try using a blend of mozzarella and shredded Parmesan. 

If you’re feeling adventurous, why not try using some crumbled feta on your next pie? Its sharp taste pairs particularly well with toppings like spinach and artichoke.

And if you want to add some extra kick to your pizza, mix in some shredded Pepper Jack or sliced jalapenos. 

man making pizza on kitchen island

Top your pizza with shredded mozzarella and parmesan cheese. Then add fresh basil.

rolled out pizza dough with sauce and basil on top

How to Make a pizza in 7 Easy Steps:

  • Prepare sauce
  • Roll out dough
  • Top dough with sauce, shredded cheese, and fresh basil
  • Place on pizza peel
  • Launch into Ooni
  • Cook for 1 to 2 minutes (temp 600 to 800 degrees)
  • Cut pizza & enjoy! 
pizza on pizza peel going into ooni

Using a pizza peel like this one makes transferring pizza so easy! We also use this one! 

pizza pie in ooni

Ooni pizza makers are literally the best way to make homemade pizza in minutes!

Our Ooni pizza oven linked here!

With the Holidays Coming these Make Great Gift Ideas

pizza pie on counter

Did you catch what the secret ingredient was? It’s the Tuscan Herb Extra Virgin Infused Oil from Saratoga Olive Oil Company. Rather than use a ‘simple’ olive oil, Andrew added the Tuscan Herb Oil which is filled with a fresh herb blend of oregano, basil, garlic, and rosemary for the most amazing sauce and flavor!

Not a fan of tomato sauce but love pasta? This easy 3 ingredient pasta salad may be just for you.

Another great choice would be this olive oil! Saratoga Olive Oil Company is known to have the freshest olive oil. 

green thumbtack

Have you checked out my other social channels? Follow along so you don’t miss out on any of my tips, recipes, or stories! ( you know I love a good story ūüėČ  Join me on my other social channels for more! Pinterest, Instagram, and Facebook

  • You won’t want to miss Andrew in motion tossing up the pizza dough. Be sure to check out my Instagram post as well. 

Now that you know how to make your own pizza sauce, what’s your favorite topping? Will you try something new or stick with your old standbys? We hope you give this recipe a try and let us know how it turns out. And if you have any questions about the process, don’t hesitate to reach out in the comments below.

Susan Signature with feather pen
fall diy door hanger that is black and white stripe with fall colored flowers on it
DIY | Easy Crafts | Fall

Easy to Make Round Wood DIY Door Hanger for Fall

Hey there, crafty friend! Are you ready to dive headfirst into the wonderful world of¬†DIY door hangers? Picture this: a cozy afternoon with your favorite tunes playing in the background, a table overflowing with colorful paints and craft supplies, and an empty¬†wooden door hanger¬†just waiting for your creative touch. It’s like a mini canvas for your¬†front door, and trust me, the possibilities are endless for a new pretty¬†welcome sign.

collander of fresh basil
Main Dishes | Salads | Side Dishes

Easy Nut-Free Pesto Recipe You Can Make in 10 Minutes

Pesto is a flavorful sauce that can be used in a variety of dishes. ¬†Traditional pesto¬†is usually made with basil, olive oil,¬†Parmesan cheese,¬†pine nuts, and garlic, and it‚Äôs a¬†great way¬†to add flavor to pasta, chicken, or fish. But what if you have¬†nut allergies? Not to worry. I’ve got the perfect¬†easy nut-free pesto recipe you can make in 10 minutes, just for you.¬†

sauteed ravioli on plate with sundried tomatoes, artichokes and capers
Appetizers | Main Dishes

Can you Saute Ravioli Instead of Boiling? Best How to Recipe

Have you ever wondered? Can you saute ravioli instead of boiling it? Imagine a world where crispy, golden pockets of pasta filled with delectable ingredients are just a sizzle away from landing on your plate. Welcome to the realm of¬†pan-fried ravioli¬†perfection, where culinary simplicity meets Italian flair. If you’ve ever yearned for a quick and scrumptious meal that’s bound to impress, you’re in for a treat!¬†

wooden board with eight different loose leaf teas on it
Beverages | Fall

The Best Fall Tea Flavors: Plus Honey that Goes with Them

As the leaves begin to don their vibrant coats of red and gold and a brisk chill settles in the air, there’s no denying that fall has arrived. It’s the season of cozy sweaters, crackling fires, and of course, the comforting embrace of a warm cup of tea. While the world of tea offers a vast array of flavors year-round, there’s something undeniably magical about the unique brews that emerge during autumn. In this post, we’ll journey through the best¬†fall tea flavors.


  1. We make homemade pizza all the time (or I should say Brian makes it all the time!) and I can’t wait to try Andrew’s recipe! Love seeing him in action! Thanks for sharing! ~Missy

  2. 5 stars
    Oh my goodness it looks delicious. My son is our resident pizza maker so I will definitely let him know about the oil. How nice that it is infused with all those herbs.

  3. 5 stars
    Wow, Now I know what to buy David for his birthday, an OONI! LOL, I thought you misspelled onion.
    Can’t wait to put Andrews’s recipe to the test.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating